Publication of FY2013 business evaluation

A part of the green space on the west side of the newly designated health center in the green space on the south side of Benten Cave is donated to the city.

-Negotiations with landowners are commendable.
- The fact that the candidate sites were not 100% approved was unavoidable, as it would have meant that landowners would have no freedom to do what they wanted.
・New designations are also progressing, albeit slowly, through on-site inspections and other measures.
- Although a new designation was made, the green space on the west side of the health center, which is of a similar size, was dedesignated, so even though it was a donation, the area did not increase, and so the designation can be "somewhat evaluated."
-We appreciate that part of the designated green space has been donated to the city.
-We have been paying attention to the state of management of the north side of Hiraoen since it was designated as green space, and recently it does not appear to be in a state of complete neglect.
・In places with lots of greenery, there is probably inheritance among landowners. I think it was good that there was a donation.
It will be difficult to get approval from all the landowners.
・"Green" from existing urban areas ring ( ) It is unfortunate that another large sloped green space that forms part of the "Hakone Park" has been purchased. Perhaps it would be wise to consider reconsidering the order of designation.
- Because this is work that involves lobbying landowners, there is some unavoidable downsizing in the process from candidate to implementation.
- The donation of green spaces can be considered a step forward in terms of the intent of the system, but the fact that the actual quantities are offset and recorded as zero could lead to a miscalculation. As for the newly designated areas, I think that the quantities should be listed as positive results, even though they are smaller than the planned area. Rather, this is probably because the goals and evaluations were not set appropriately. A possible system would be one in which the goal is to maintain the designated status, and any conversion to land use would be evaluated as a negative, while any conversion that maintains the intent, such as donations, would be evaluated as a zero or positive.

・This will need to be carefully considered in the future.
・I think it is very difficult. Even if you can do it, you have to keep going.
- There is no activity process or collaboration with volunteer groups.
・The goal is to invite participants to participate in the activity, but there is no mention of this, so it is not worthy of evaluation.
- Why not approach local residents' associations that have an attachment to the proposed implementation areas?
- Given the location of the proposed site, it seems difficult for volunteer groups to establish their activities.
・Forest ( ) Land management requires specialized knowledge, so I think it is important to take the time to develop it.
・First of all, I would like the city to take the lead.
・This kind of project cannot be prepared by the city alone. Even before the mechanisms and systems are in place, it is necessary to convey the city's awareness of the problem and to find out what the system should be and what its bottlenecks are by contacting potential volunteers at a stage with a high degree of freedom. In other words, it seems necessary to consider recruiting people who are interested, even though nothing has been decided yet.

Partial maintenance of facilities of Shimotsukado Children's Square

・Efforts can be evaluated.
・I would like to evaluate that the advance maintenance was completed.
・The goal is to consider opening four parks equally. It can only be said that the partial maintenance of Shimotsukado alone can be evaluated somewhat. I think it's either that the goal was set poorly or the evaluation was too lenient.
・Nakayoshi Children's Square is well managed and suitable for use as a park.
・It would be nice if we could do some maintenance and open space.
・We deserve evaluation that we were able to maintain ahead of next year's schedule and expect that maintenance of other parks gains momentum.
・Since the use of land seems to be dynamic, it may be necessary to use this system to unearth suitable sites and candidate sites, and to create a concept that is tailored to the park. Otherwise, the number of jobs will decrease after the second period.
・It is certain that there are not enough parks in existing urban areas, so with a view to maximizing the potential of this system, I would like you to continue to explore the possibility of grasping the circumstances of landowners and mobilizing them.

Fureai Children's Square (fence repair), Inagi Central Park Baseball Field (toilet repair), White Road ( ) Children's Square (water tap installed), etc.

・Maintenance work can be evaluated.
・Piazzas and parks with updated playground equipment stand out and can be appreciated.
・Maintenance is important, but I want people to use the equipment with care.
・There is no way to evaluate if the target is “as needed” and the report is “executed within the budget”. Municipal governments need to carry out their work in a matter-of-fact manner, but at the very least, I would like the report to include the deployment methods and the status of the "inspection survey" that is one of the goals, as well as the results of grasping the "citizen's voice." We think that it is important as a report of goals and evaluation, such as whether the review meeting was held and how the situation of the current facility was evaluated.

Koyodai Elementary School (255.8 square meters) and Inagi Fourth Junior High School (394.5 square meters) were converted to lawns (both improved grass).
Reconstruction of the former Inagi Daiichi Elementary School building and new construction of Nanzan Elementary School (provisional name), which incorporates rooftop greenery in the design, begins

・It is progressing as planned and can be evaluated. I would like to expect cooperation with the school for future maintenance.
・It is commendable that the project was carried out according to the target.
・Last year's Hirao Elementary School and 2nd Junior High School were in better grass than last year, and visually they are better in comparison with the ground.
・I think it would be good if there was even a little grass in the school grounds of the whole school.
・I saw the playground of Koyodai Elementary School, but it was far from what I had imagined, with only a patch in one corner of the playground. Area is shown in the report column mentioned above, but may it be hard to say "lawn of school grounds?"
I wanted a more specific explanation of “what was the original plan” and “what parts were realized and which were not”.
・ Above all, I think that the opinions of the educational field (schools, parents) should be respected, so I think it will be difficult to make a leap forward.
・I am pleased to see that there is steady progress. It is a pity that we cannot see the concrete plan for continuous maintenance as the maintenance progresses in the future. If you are considering possible problems and consideration of countermeasures, I would like you to report on them.
・The goal is to target all elementary and junior high schools in the city, and the measures are diverse, such as schoolyards, rooftops, walls, and curtains, so a master plan is necessary to realize it. I think that some environments are not suitable for greening, but I hope that they will be evaluated and reflected in specific annual targets.

・Implemented almost as planned.
・Each facility is working hard to create a green curtain.
・I want to evaluate what I was able to do. We want you to push forward enforcement to school where construction has not yet started. In addition, the goal is not only to continue, but also to further improve the quality of research, such as more effective types of research.
・I think it would be good to show children a specific example of positive greenery creation. It also has practical effects.
・It is desirable that green curtains will be used at home as well.
・I would like to thank you for your cooperation on the ground.
・Considering the scale of the school building area, it seems that the implementation area (not the curtain area but the planting range plane area) is not so large. In the future, it is expected that the activities will be expanded to include the expansion of the implementation area and the ideal use of the land on the school grounds as it continues.

Second nursery school: Growing flowers enriches children's hearts. With the green curtains, you can feel the sunshine in the summer and the flowers close to you. By growing vegetables in a nursery school, children can experience the love, importance, and difficulty of food, leading to food education.
No. 3 nursery school: Green curtains are now available to protect against the sun. In addition, the scenery has improved, and we are making steady progress towards our goal.
4th nursery school: By keeping the flowers in the planters always blooming, and by cultivating and harvesting vegetables, and cooking and eating them by themselves, children not only grow plants, but also increase their interest in food. rice field.
No. 5 nursery school: Children take the initiative in collecting seeds.

・Can be implemented as planned.
・The stance of efforts such as verification of effects is remarkable. I would like to expect further improvement in quality.
・Although the area has decreased from last year, the curtains are installed in appropriate places.
・I think it is good for children to see how flowers bloom and bear fruit. I want you to become familiar with greening from a young age.
・Thank you for your cooperation. Imagining it calms me down.
・Although only municipal nursery schools that are directly involved are reported here, they represent only a small portion of all kindergartens and nursery schools in the city. Even if you can't ask private facilities to keep pace with the implementation, are there any efforts or results? If private sector cooperation is essential for early childhood care and education, then the objectives and benefits described here are expected to spread to private facilities, and there have been reports of efforts to this end at these forums. Thank you.

・Implemented as planned.
・I want the quality to be further improved. (Correlation between the implementation period of the green curtain and the growth state of the plant, whether the plant is effective during the period when the shade is required, etc.)
・Although fewer than last year, curtains are being made smoothly.
・As we think that it is kind that it is easy to bring up that many bitter gourds are installed, we want you to inflect very much.
・Why don't you make a budget if necessary and have it executed exactly? I think it's only natural that we can't ensure quality by relying on the goodwill of the facility.
・Although it can be said that it is actually implemented, the installation area does not seem to be so large compared to the scale of the facility. In order for green curtains and rooftop greening to have environmental significance, and for the development of a city full of greenery where you can feel the greenery, as a numerical target, we assume not only the number of facilities installed but also the area, and future activities We want you to try for expansion in.
・I think it's good to be cool without taking time and effort.

・Maintenance was done.
・I would like you to improve the quality, such as measures to further demonstrate the effect.
・If the rooftop greening can be visualized, the management will be more motivated.
・The breeding situation is not so good. I feel the need to help.
・I think it will be difficult to manage due to the heat this year, but I want them to grow well.
・Why don't you consider making a budget as necessary and having it come true exactly? I think it's only natural that we can't ensure quality by relying on the goodwill of the facility manager.
・It will be a steady effort considering the target facilities, but I would like to expect it to be continued.

Maintenance of rooftop greenery at Shiroyama Experience Learning Center
Tree species ( ) : Sedum, white clover, screw pine, etc. Area: Approximately 950 square meters Growth status: Normal

・Maintenance is done.
・Pay attention to waterproofing.
・I would like you to improve the quality, such as measures to further demonstrate the effect.
・Since there are few opportunities for people to see it, I feel that the motivation of the company that manages it is not good.
・Maybe because of the heat, the growth condition was not so good, and some of them seemed to be dying.
・I think it will grow well because it is a strong flower.
・Why don't you consider making a budget as necessary and having it come true exactly? I think it's only natural that we can't ensure quality by relying on the goodwill of the facility manager.
・Since the site is large and can be overlooked from the park next door, we hope that it will continue to be maintained. Since the energy-saving effect can be expected, I think it would be even better if the effect is widely disseminated.

Inagi City Hospital Health Check Outpatient Ward ( )・Implementation of rooftop greenery on multi-storey car park
Tree species ( ) ：Ryunohige, Abelia, Azalea, Haki, Yamabuki, etc. Area: About 540 square meters Condition: Good

Maintenance is being carried out as scheduled.
・I would like to see the quality improved, including measures to make the program even more effective.
・Tree species ( ) The plantings take advantage of the site's unique characteristics, are well maintained, and provide a sense of peace from the hospital.
・It is very well maintained, but it's a shame that people don't often go all the way to the top.
・I think the quality is high.

Maintenance and management of greening on the roof of Inagi City Health Plaza Tree species: Ryunohige Area: Approx. 400 square meters Growing status: Normal

・Maintenance is done.
・I would like you to improve the quality, such as measures to further demonstrate the effect.
・I feel more motivated if there is a way to visualize.
・It seemed to be growing smoothly.
・Ryunohige, which is resistant to heat, has strong roots and is easy to grow.
・Would you consider making a budget if necessary and having it come true exactly? I think it's only natural that we can't ensure quality by relying on the goodwill of the facility manager.

・Shiroyama Park needs to consider management methods in the future.
・Maintenance is difficult.
・It is necessary to clarify the definition of “natural tree shape” and quickly determine the method for that purpose.
- I would like a concrete description of what training management method was considered.
・As a place that symbolizes the lush greenery of Inagi, I would like to request a management method that gives a sense of the natural shape of the trees.
・I'm looking forward to seeing how it goes.
・Why don't you publish which areas or which trees are under natural tree shape management and try to conduct experimental management?
・There is no way to evaluate it with a report that the study is the goal and that it is still being explored.

Examination of maintenance management that gives a sense of natural tree shape (road)

－ (Review of implementation period)

・We will continue to monitor the situation in the future.
・It is quite difficult. Needs care.
・It is necessary to clarify the definition of “natural tree shape” and quickly determine the method for that purpose.
・If a management method cannot be found, the current situation should be evaluated.
・If it is not implemented, it cannot be evaluated.
·I'm looking forward to.
・There are no particular plans to include it in large-scale development such as the Nanshan East Land Readjustment Project. In the category of "road", if it seems difficult to manage trees that give a sense of natural shape, I think it would be good to set up a study group and conclude that they are "unsuitable for roadside trees". How about excluding roadside trees that are planted at equal intervals along the road and shifting to explore other possibilities? For example, if it is incorporated into a large-scale development in the future, such as the corner of the median strip, the center of the "roundabout" that has been attracting attention recently, or the center of the culdesac, it will be dignified.
・Regarding flowering trees, I would like you to consider the timing of pruning as soon as possible.
・For roadside trees with various restrictions, I think that the goal of management that gives a sense of natural tree shape is also a high hurdle. I would appreciate it if you could give me a report on the plan for future development.
・How about setting a pruning standard tree and using it as a standard?

(Tentative name) Minamiyama Elementary School new construction started

・The project was implemented as planned.
・I would like you to proceed as planned, including the green modeling.
・I want elementary schools to practice the creation of greenery such as rooftop greening.
・Because it is a new school, it may be possible to do something different from others.
・I don't know the details, but I'm looking forward to it.
・It is difficult to evaluate from the outside at this time, but I hope that the environmental creation of the new elementary school will become a model for the existing schools in the city.

・We were able to proceed smoothly.
・I would like to proceed as planned, including the green molding.
・The greening rate is high, and I am looking forward to the completion of the townscape.
・I am looking forward to becoming a beautiful district.
• We are pleased that district planning decisions are proceeding smoothly in the business district. There are also expectations that this will be implemented in existing urban areas through the initiative of residents, so we are also looking forward to initiatives such as publicity activities aimed at areas other than the target areas.

・The event was carried out as planned.
・Rather than thinking of "performing the work" as "human resource development," I would like you to clarify the human resource development plan in order to further improve quality.
・undergrowth ( ) We hope to evaluate the differences in technical skills, such as mowing and repairing wooden decks, and secure the desired talent.
・There appears to be a lag in terms of human resource development and organization.
・Since it is a new district, I think a good organization will be formed.
・I hope this will continue.
・I think it was a great achievement to be able to establish an area management organization in FY2012, which was the purpose of the study. I understand that you were able to work with that organization in FY2013, so things are going smoothly.

Consider securing human resources

・We will continue to carefully consider this matter.
・It will be a challenging undertaking.
・If the method cannot be determined, it is not possible to secure human resources. Therefore, the method should be determined as a top priority. Then, in order to secure human resources, Measures ( ) I would like you to consider this.
- Regarding securing human resources, why not approach local neighborhood associations near the proposed development site through the local neighborhood association federation?
・With the increase in the elderly population, I think it would be good to make adoption systems more widely known and to generate volunteers in local communities. From this, perhaps the seeds of volunteer activities will emerge.
・It is unfortunate that the report is not specific. Without a report on what aspects were considered and what the results were, it is impossible to evaluate properly.

- In the future, Shiroyama Park will need to consider installing signs to protect valuable plants from theft.
・There appears to be a lag in terms of human resource development and organization.
・I would like the plan to be revised.
・I would like the implementation to proceed without delay until the final goal.
・Nothing has been done.
・I'm looking forward to next year.
・Tree name plate ( ) The installation of the trees can be evaluated as an activity that is expected to raise the level of awareness of greenery that citizens have latent. Although it has not been completed this year, this is unavoidable if there are obvious obstacles such as a busy schedule for events. I look forward to future activities.

Carry out various awareness-raising activities (including roadside trees) Tree name plate ( ) Installation)

- Why is the implementation schedule being reviewed? Tree name plate ( ) I think it might be possible to consider the design at a desk.
・I think it's fun to know the names of plants and trees.
・Tree name plate ( ) The installation of these parks can be evaluated as an activity that is expected to have the effect of raising citizens' potential interest in greenery to a conscious level.
- It is possible that the implementation schedule may be reviewed, and this in itself is not a problem, but if the implementation of a goal that has been set, even at the consideration level, is postponed, it needs to be properly evaluated.

Although in part, Tree name plate ( ) We have installed

・Tree name plate ( ) The goal is to install them in parks, roadside plantations, and schools, so can we start wherever possible?
- Isn't it necessary to review the plan by clarifying which schools will be implementing it each year?
・The goal setting is poor. It is impossible to evaluate the program if it is not clear which schools it will be implemented in.
・Park Road School Tree name plate ( ) I think this is effective in raising public interest in greenery.
・In various places Tree name plate ( ) I think it would be good to have one.
・Tree name plate ( ) The installation of these parks can be evaluated as an activity that is expected to have the effect of raising citizens' potential interest in greenery to a conscious level.

New information is updated on the Inagi City website from time to time, and efforts are made to provide easy-to-understand information (cherry blossom information, moss phlox information, charging for parking, how to use the park, etc.)　

・Necessary information is provided.
・Furthermore, I would like you to improve the mechanism (quality) that can provide information to elderly people who do not use computers much.
・How about cooperation with sightseeing business department in the field of vision? ・Does it become such a results report every year? You can evaluate if you report what you did and when, but you can't evaluate it with the same report every year.
・The homepage has various information and you can feel water and greenery.
- I would like to see specific reports describing the achievements. The goal is to update as needed, but it is difficult to evaluate it without mentioning how many times it has been updated as a result, and whether this matter and this matter have been exhausted.
・Information about the parking lot charge and how to use the park is naturally necessary as a manager, and I don't think it is included in the project policy of "collecting and providing information on water and greenery." I look forward to your future activities.
・Isn't it necessary to devise ways to make it easier to access the website?