Publication of business evaluation for fiscal year 2013

Part of the newly designated health center green space on the south side of Benten Cave will be donated to the city.

- Negotiations with landowners can be evaluated.
・The reason why the candidate site was not 100% approved is unavoidable because the landowner has no freedom.
・New designations are progressing, albeit only slightly, with on-site inspections being carried out.
・Although the new designation was achieved, the green space on the west side of the health center, which has the same area, was removed from the designation even though it was donated, so the area could not be increased, so it can be evaluated as ``somewhat.''
・We appreciate the donation of a portion of the already designated green space to the city.
・We have been paying attention to the management status of the north side of Hiraoen after it was designated as a green space, and recently it appears that it has not been maintained at all.
・Where there is a lot of greenery, it may be due to the inheritance of landowners. I think it was a good thing that there was a donation.
・I think it will be difficult to obtain approval from all landowners.
・It is unfortunate that another large sloped green area that forms a ``green ring'' from the existing urban area has been acquired. You may also want to consider reconsidering the order in which they are specified.
・Since it is a ``responsive'' job of reaching out to landowners, it is unavoidable that there will be a reduction in the process from candidate to implementation.
・The donation of green areas is considered to be a step forward in terms of the purpose of the system, but the fact that the actual quantity is offset and written as zero may mislead the evaluation. Regarding the newly designated land, I think that the quantity should be cited as a positive result even though the area is smaller than the planned area. Rather, it is probably because the goals and evaluation settings were not necessarily appropriate. A system can be considered in which a goal is to maintain the designated status, and a change to land use is given a negative rating, while a conversion that maintains the intended purpose, such as a donation, is given a zero or positive rating.

・This will need to be carefully considered in the future.
・I think it is very difficult. We must continue even if we can.
・Activity process and cooperation with volunteer organizations are not visible.
・The goal is to invite activity participants, but there is no mention of this and it is not worthy of evaluation.
・Why not approach the neighborhood association that has a strong attachment to the proposed implementation site?
・Due to the location of the candidate site, it seems difficult for volunteer groups to take root in their activities.
- Forest land management requires specialized knowledge, so I think it is important to take the time to cultivate it.
・First of all, I would like the city to take the lead.
・This type of project cannot be arranged by the city alone. Even before the mechanisms and systems are in place, it is not necessary to communicate the city's awareness of issues and explore the system and its bottlenecks through contact with potential volunteers at a highly flexible stage. mosquito. In other words, it seems necessary to consider ways of soliciting information such as ``Nothing has been decided yet, but is there anyone who is interested?''

Partial maintenance of facilities at Shimotsukado Children's Square

・Efforts can be appreciated.
・I would like to commend the fact that advance preparations were made.
・The goal is to open four plazas equally. With only Shimotsukado being partially developed, it can only be said that it is somewhat worthy of praise. I think that either the goal was poorly set or the evaluation was too lenient.
- Nakayoshi Children's Square is managed so that it is suitable for use, and I think it is suitable as a leased park.
・It would be nice if the area could be developed little by little and a plaza could be created.
・The fact that the development was completed ahead of next year's schedule is commendable, and we hope that this will provide impetus for the development of other parks.
・Land use seems to be dynamic, so it is necessary to base the park on a leased land system, find suitable sites and potential sites that utilize this system, and create a plan to complete the project. Otherwise, there will be less work in the second and subsequent phases.
- It is certain that there are not enough parks in existing urban areas, so with a view to maximizing the potential of this system, we would like the government to continue to understand the circumstances of landowners and explore the possibility of liquidating land.

Fureai Children's Square (fence repair), Inagi Central Park Baseball Stadium (restroom renovations), Hakudo Children's Square (hydrant installation), etc.

- Maintenance work can be evaluated.
- Squares and parks with updated playground equipment are visible and can be appreciated.
・While maintenance is important, we want the users to use the equipment with care.
・There is no way to evaluate if the goal is ``as needed'' and the report is ``executed within the budget.'' It is necessary for municipal governments to proceed with their work in a calm manner, but at the very least, I would like them to include in their reports the status of the ``inspection surveys'' that are included in the development methods and goals, and the results of understanding ``citizen voices.'' We believe that it is important to report goals and evaluations, such as whether review meetings were held and how the current situation of the facilities was evaluated.

The schoolyards of Koyodai Elementary School (255.8 square meters) and Inagi Daishi Junior High School (394.5 square meters) were converted to grass (both with improved grass).
Started construction work including rebuilding the old school building of Inagi Daiichi Elementary School and new construction of Nanzan Elementary School (tentative name), which included rooftop greenery in the design.

・Progress is progressing as planned and can be evaluated. We hope to collaborate with the school regarding future maintenance and management.
・It can be evaluated that the project was implemented according to the target.
・The current state of the turf in Hirao Elementary and 2nd Middle School last year is better than last year, and it looks good visually compared to the ground.
・I think it would be good if all schools had grass in their schoolyards.
・I looked at the schoolyard at Koyodai Elementary School, and there was only a patch in one corner of the schoolyard, which was far from what I had imagined. Although the area is shown in the report column above, I think it would be difficult to call it ``turning the schoolyard into a lawn''.
I would have liked a more specific explanation of ``what was the original plan?'' and ``which parts were realized and which were not.''
・I believe that the opinions of the educational community (schools, parents) should be respected above all else, so I think it will be difficult to make a leap forward.
・I am pleased to see that there is steady progress. As the construction progresses in the future, continuous maintenance and management will be necessary, but it is unfortunate that we cannot see a concrete plan for this. If you are considering possible problems and countermeasures, I would like you to report on them.
-The target targets all elementary and junior high schools in the city, and the measures include a variety of measures including schoolyards, rooftops, walls, curtains, etc., so a master plan is needed to realize it. I believe that there are some environments where greening is not suitable, but I hope that these will be evaluated and reflected in specific annual targets.

・The project has been carried out almost as planned.
-Each facility is making an effort to create green curtains.
・I would like to commend the program for being implemented. I would like to see it implemented in schools where construction has not yet commenced. In addition, the goal is not just to continue the program, but to further improve the quality by conducting more effective research.
・I think it would be good to show children a concrete example of proactive greening. The practical effects are also meaningful.
- It is hoped that by putting up green curtains, people will also start doing the same at home.
I would like to thank the staff for their cooperation on site.
・Considering the size of the school building area, the implementation area (not the curtain area but the planar area of ​​the planting area) does not seem to be that large. I hope that in the future, the implementation area will be expanded as the project continues and that the activities will be expanded to include the way in which the land is used within the school grounds.

2nd Nursery School: Growing flowers enriches children's hearts. The green curtains provide protection from the summer sun and allow you to feel closer to the flowers. By growing vegetables in a nursery school, children can experience the love, importance, and difficulty of food, which leads to food education.
Nursery School 3: Green curtains now provide protection from sunlight. Furthermore, the scenery has improved and we are well on our way to achieving our goal.
Nursery School 4: By making sure that the flowers in the planters are always blooming, and by growing and harvesting vegetables and cooking and eating them ourselves, we can not only help the plants grow, but also increase their interest in food. Ta.
Nursery School 5: Children are also taking the initiative in collecting seeds.

・We were able to implement the project as planned.
・The efforts are remarkable, such as verifying the effects. I hope that the quality will further improve.
・Although the area is smaller than last year, curtains have been installed in appropriate locations.
・I think it's good for children to be able to see flowers blooming and fruit forming. I want children to become familiar with greening from an early age.
・Thank you for your cooperation on site. Imagining it is soothing.
・Only municipal nursery schools that are directly involved are reported here, but this is only a small portion of all kindergartens and nursery schools in the city. Even if it is not possible to ask private facilities to implement the measures in unison, are there any efforts to be made or any results? If it is inevitable to obtain cooperation from the private sector for early childhood care and education, the objectives and benefits described here are expected to spread to private facilities as well, and efforts to achieve this are also reported in such forums. I'm grateful.

・It is being carried out as planned.
・I would like to see further improvements in quality (such as the correlation between the duration of the green curtain and the growth status of the plants, and whether the plants are effective during periods when shade is needed).
・Although there are fewer curtains than last year, they are being made smoothly.
- The fact that there are so many bitter melons indicates that they are an easy variety to grow, so I hope that people will make good use of them.
・Why not set up a budget as necessary and have them carry it out properly? If you just rely on the goodwill of the facilities, it's only natural that you won't be able to ensure quality.
・Even if it can be said that it is being implemented in the written sense, the installation area does not seem to be that large compared to the size of the facility. In order for green curtains and rooftop greening to have environmental significance, and in order to create a town that is rich in greenery and feels green, I would like to see numerical targets set not only for the number of facilities installed but also for the area, and efforts to expand in future activities.
・I think it's good that it's easy and cools you down.

・Maintenance and management were successful.
・I would like the quality of measures to be improved to be even more effective.
・If you can visualize your rooftop greenery, you will be more motivated to manage it.
・The breeding situation is not very good. I feel the need to make some changes.
・I think it will be difficult to manage them due to this year's heat, but I hope they will grow well.
・Why not consider setting up a budget as needed and having it implemented exactly? I think it's natural that quality cannot be ensured just by relying on the goodwill of facility managers.
- Considering the target facilities, this will be a modest effort, but I hope that it will be continued.

Rooftop greening maintenance and management at Shiroyama Experience Learning Center Tree species: Sedum, white clover, screwbrush, etc. Area: Approximately 950 square meters Growth status: Average

・It is maintained and managed.
・Be careful about waterproofing.
・I would like the quality of measures to be improved to be even more effective.
・Because there are few opportunities for people to see it, I feel that the motivation of the companies that manage it is low.
・Perhaps because of the heat, the growth conditions were not very good, and some of the plants appeared to be dying.
・It is a strong flowering plant, so I think it will be well cultivated.
・Why not consider setting up a budget as needed and having it implemented exactly? I think it's natural that quality cannot be ensured just by relying on the goodwill of facility managers.
・This site is large in size and can be overlooked from the park next door, so we hope that it will be continuously maintained. Since the project is of such a scale that energy-saving effects can be expected, I think it would be even better if the effects could be disseminated widely.

Implementation of greening on the roof of Inagi City Hospital medical examination outpatient building (Garaito) and multi-story parking lot Tree species: Ryuunohike, Ahelia, Tsutsushi, Haki, Yamabuki, etc. Area: Approximately 540 square meters Growth status: Good

・Maintenance is being carried out as scheduled.
・I would like the quality of measures to be improved to be even more effective.
-The planting takes advantage of the characteristics of each tree species, is well-managed, and gives a sense of peace to the hospital.
・Although it is very well maintained, it is a shame that it often does not go all the way to the top.
・I think the quality is high.

Inagi City Health Plaza rooftop greening maintenance and management Tree species: Ryunohige Area: Approximately 400 square meters Growth status: Average

・It is maintained and managed.
・I would like the quality of measures to be improved to be even more effective.
・I feel that motivation will increase if there is a way to visualize it.
・It seemed to be growing smoothly.
・I think Ryunohige is easy to grow because it doesn't succumb to heat and its roots spread out well.
・Why not consider setting up a budget as needed and having it implemented exactly? I think it's natural that quality cannot be ensured just by relying on the goodwill of facility managers.

・Future management methods for Shiroyama Park will need to be considered.
・It is difficult to maintain.
- It is necessary to clearly define what "natural tree form" is and quickly identify the methods to achieve it.
・I would like a specific description of what training management methods were considered.
・As this is a place that symbolizes the abundant greenery of Inagi, I hope that management methods will be implemented that allow the natural tree shapes to be preserved.
・I'm looking forward to seeing how it turns out.
- Why not publicize which areas or trees are being managed using natural tree forms and conduct some experimental management?
- The goal is to examine the issue, and a report stating that the matter is still being explored makes it impossible to evaluate.

Consideration of maintenance that allows natural tree shapes to be felt (roads)

- (Review of implementation timing)

・We will implement this while monitoring the future situation.
・It's quite difficult. Needs care.
・It is necessary to clarify the definition of “natural tree shape” and quickly identify a method for achieving it.
- If a management method cannot be found, the current situation should be evaluated.
- Cannot be evaluated if it has not been implemented.
·I'm looking forward to.
・There are no plans to incorporate it into large-scale developments such as the Nanzan Eastern Land Readjustment Project. If it seems difficult to manage the tree to give it a natural appearance in the ``road'' classification, I think it would be a good idea to set up a review committee and conclude that the tree is not suitable for use as a roadside tree. Why not exclude street trees planted at equal intervals along roads and shift to exploring other possibilities? For example, if it is incorporated into a large-scale development in the future, such as a corner of a median strip, the center of a roundabout that has recently attracted attention, or the center of a culdesac, it will create a sense of style.
- Regarding flowering trees, I would like you to consider the timing of pruning as soon as possible.
- Regarding street trees, which have various restrictions, I think the goal of managing them to give a sense of natural tree shape is quite a hurdle. I would be grateful if you could give me a report on your plans for future developments.
・How about establishing a standard tree for pruning and using it as a standard?

Construction work begins on new Nanzan Elementary School (tentative name)

・The project was implemented as planned.
・I would like the project to proceed as planned, including the green design.
・I would like elementary schools to practice green creation such as rooftop greening.
・Since it's a new school, maybe we can do something different from others?
・I don't know the details, but I have high hopes.
・Although it is difficult to evaluate externally at this time, we hope that the environment created at the new elementary school will become a model for existing schools in the city.

・We were able to proceed smoothly.
・We want to proceed as planned, including the green design.
・The greening rate is high, and we are looking forward to the completion of the townscape.
・I am looking forward to becoming a beautiful area.
・I am glad that the decision on the district plan for the project area is progressing smoothly. There is hope that this will be realized even in established urban areas through the initiative of residents, so we are also looking forward to efforts such as public relations activities aimed at areas other than the target areas.

・The project was implemented as planned.
- Rather than thinking that "work implementation = human resource development", I would like to see a clear human resource development plan to further improve quality.
・We hope to evaluate differences in technical aspects such as mowing underbrush and repairing wooden decks, and secure the human resources we aim for.
・It appears to be lagging behind in terms of human resource development and organization.
・Since it is a new district, I think a good organization will be formed.
・I hope that it will continue.
・I believe that the establishment of an area management organization in FY 2010, which was the purpose of this study, was a major achievement. I was able to work with that organization in FY2015, and I understand that things are progressing smoothly.

Considering securing human resources

・We will continue to carefully consider the matter.
・This will be a difficult endeavor.
・If the method cannot be determined, it will not be possible to secure human resources. Therefore, the method should be determined as a top priority. Based on this, I would like them to consider measures to secure human resources.
- Regarding securing human resources, why not approach the neighborhood associations near the planned development site through the association of neighborhood associations?
・With the increase in the number of elderly people, I think it would be a good idea to make the Adapt system more familiar and create volunteer opportunities in nearby areas. Perhaps this is where the seeds of volunteer activities will emerge.
・It is unfortunate that the report is not specific. An accurate evaluation cannot be made without a report on what aspects were considered and what the results were.

・In the future, Shiroyama Park will need to consider installing display boards to protect valuable plants from grave theft.
・It appears to be lagging behind in terms of human resource development and organization.
・We request that the plan be revised.
・I would like the implementation to proceed without delay until reaching the final goal.
・I haven't done anything.
・I look forward to next year.
- The installation of tree name boards can be evaluated as an activity that can be expected to have the effect of raising citizens' latent interest in greenery to a conscious level. Although it is said that it will not be completed this year, it is unavoidable if there are obvious obstacles such as a busy schedule of events. I look forward to your future activities.

Implementation of various public awareness activities (installation of tree name boards on street trees)

・Why is the implementation timing being revised? I think it would be possible to consider the design of the tree name board even on paper.
・I think it's fun to learn the names of plants and trees.
- The installation of tree name boards can be evaluated as an activity that can be expected to have the effect of raising citizens' latent interest in greenery to a conscious level.
・It is possible to review the implementation timing, and this in itself is not a problem, but if the implementation of a goal that has been set as a goal has been postponed, even if it is at the consideration level, it is necessary to evaluate it correctly. .

Tree name boards have been installed in some areas.

・Since the target for installing tree name boards is in parks, roadside planting, and schools, is it possible to do so in places where possible?
・Is it not necessary to revise the plan after specifying which schools will be implemented each year?
- Poor goal setting. There is no way to evaluate the program unless it is clearly stated in which schools it will be implemented.
・I think that tree name boards at park and road schools are effective in increasing citizens' interest in greenery.
・I think it would be a good idea to have tree name boards in various places.
- The installation of tree name boards can be evaluated as an activity that can be expected to have the effect of raising citizens' latent interest in greenery to a conscious level.

New information is constantly updated on the Inagi City website, and efforts are being made to provide easy-to-understand information (cherry blossom information, moss phlox information, paid parking, how to use the park, etc.)　

- Necessary information is provided.
・I would also like to see improvements in the system (quality) that allows information to be provided to elderly people who do not use computers much.
・Why not consider collaborating with the tourism business department? ・Will performance reports like this be made every year? You can evaluate your performance by reporting specifically what you did and when you did it, but you cannot evaluate your performance by reporting the same things every year.
・The homepage has a lot of information and you can feel the water and greenery.
・We would like to see a concrete report regarding achievements. The goal is to update as often as possible, but it is difficult to evaluate the results unless there is a record of how many times the update has been made, or whether this topic has been completed.
・Notifications regarding parking charges and how to use the park are things that managers naturally have to do, and I don't think they are included in the project policy of ``collecting and providing information on water and greenery.'' I look forward to your future activities.
・Isn't it necessary to devise ways to make accessing the homepage easier?